I’m going to make a lot of people angry with my list (if anyone actually reads this thing). Keep in mind that this is my list. It will differ from everyone else’s. Please keep in mind that my judgments are my own. I firmly believe that everyone is entitled to his or her opinion. Please keep in mind that this includes myself. That being said, nuts to everyone. This is my list and I stand by it.
Top 5 albums of 2007
5) Cassadaga, Bright Eyes – Every list needs to start with something strong. We begin with Conor Oberst. I’m a sucker for outstanding lyrics, and he never lets me down. Conor has an uncanny ability to assess the world around him and come away with track after track of truth. He’ll bring you to your knees if you give him half a chance. I suggest you give him that chance.
4) Friend and Foe, Menomena – I had this as my album of the year for a long time, but other records grew on me and unseated it. Its descent takes nothing away from its strength. Friend and Foe is different. It’s compositionally mature in a time where generic indie rock is taking over. Each song moves like a caterpillar, slow enough to analyze the sections and make you understand just how difficult it is to write compelling music. This will be hard to follow-up, although Menomena already used it followed-up I Am the Fun Blame Monster. I hope they can do it again.
3) Neon Bible, Arcade Fire – Damn. What can I say about this that hasn’t already been said? I came in understanding that I wasn’t going to get Funeral again, and I loved everything I found. The lyrical phrases conjure memories of Bruce Springsteen. How about that for indie rock? Show your colors, Will and Regine. Fly them high and sure. Anything less would be safe, and this is the year that I spit upon the safe.
2) The Stage Names, Okkervil River – I bought this album for two reasons. First, I remembered listening to The President’s Dead with a friend and finding a unique lyrical style that read like prose, and I remembered loving it. Second, the cover was very pretty. Maybe not a very good secondary reason to buy something, but it paid off. This album grew on me with every listen, and this might be a case where seeing a band perform live made me love the record even more. I will admit that may be the case, but I will defend myself by saying my love for Okkervil River was steadily growing long before I saw them perform in Portland. This is a beautiful record from start to finish. I read one critic’s assessment that said Will Sheff is Conor Oberst, Colin Meloy, and Jeff Mangum all rolled into one. That’s a pretty high standard, but it’s well warranted. “It’s just a life story, so there’s no climax.” Amen.
1) Random Spirit Lover, Sunset Rubdown – This was a late entry for me, but it quickly knocked everything out of its path with a cow catcher. Spencer Krug’s side project shows that he’s a creative force to be reckoned with. I love the artsiness. I love the cheesy Legend-esque synthesizer. I love the emotion. I love what they do with the fucking guitar. I’m still hacking my way through the concept, but I’m loving every word, every phrase, every image. Believe me. It had to take an awful lot to knock Okkervil River off the top of the mountain. Maybe I’m biased because Random Spirit Lover is freshest in my mind, but this is the only album this year where I could sit down and say, “Wow. Two or three more listens and I’m absolutely falling in love with this.” If there’s one album this year that reaffirmed my love for music and made me glad I didn’t kill myself, it’s Random Spirit Lover. This is your record of the year, people.
Honorable Mentions
Holy Fuck, Holy Fuck – Something had to get knocked out of the top 5 when Sunset Rubdown came along. Unfortunately it was Holy Fuck. This was a breath of fresh air. They put on a hell of a live show, too.
In Our Bedroom After the War, Stars – Is it irony or poetic justice that Torq gets torched by the band he trashed in The Onion? I didn’t read the article, nor did it have any bearing on whether or not Stars made it to the top 5. This was just a little too safe for me. Let me say that again with the proper emphasis. This was just a LITTLE too safe for me. It’s still a must-have for 2007. Go out and get it right now.
Four Winds EP, Bright Eyes – I can’t honestly put a glorified single in my top 5 records, but this is solid. I have lots of love for bands that can write excellent B-sides (see my love for Sleater-Kinney). “Smoke Without Fire” is better than anything on Cassadaga, and “Tourist Trap” is a modern day country classic. “The road finally gave me back, but I don’t think I’ll unpack, because I’m not sure if I live here anymore.”
Wild Mountain Country, Blitzen Trapper – I’ve been listening to this one all day. Take Revolver, melt it in the same pot as “Mississippi Queen,” give it the unpredictability of the Bastards of Fate, and then stomp on it with the heel of a cowboy boot. That’s your record. Trippy shit.
Is Is, Yeah Yeah Yeah’s – This went under a lot of radars because it’s an EP, but it’s really good. I respect any band that can put together a strong EP. I think a lot of albums would be better off as EP’s. It gets rid of the filler. I have a prime example of this later.
Most Overrated Album
Boxer, The National – The first two tracks on Boxer are solid enough, although I think “Fake Empire” needs another verse. “Mistaken For Strangers” gets me ready for the rest of the album, but the rest of the album falls short. I keep waiting for that same energy to re-emerge, but they never bring it back. Maybe that’s the point, but I don’t particularly care for it. A good album should have peaks and valleys. The National reach a peak and fall into a valley, and then it levels off far too much. This doesn’t mean I don’t like Boxer. I just don’t think it’s worthy of the attention.
Biggest Disappointment (tie)
The Reminder, Feist – Yes. Feist. This has nothing to do with the commercial. Feist could have taken a cue from the Yeah Yeah Yeah’s and simply released an EP. There are four songs on this record (the first four songs, actually) that make me swoon. The rest is filler. I can’t finish it.
Widow City, the Fiery Furnaces – Music shouldn’t be laborious. That’s what this album is. I know the Fiery Furnaces excel at inaccessibility, but I cannot listen to this album all the way through. Widow City makes me wish I were listening to something else.
Album That Grew On Me the Most
Seven Swans, Sufjan Stevens – I bought this one last year, but each time I listen to it I love it more and more. Go get it. For God’s sake, go get it.
Rediscovered and Loving It!
Vitalogy, Pearl Jam – Hell, yes.
Top 10 Albums I Bought This Year
1) The Belle of Avenue A, the Fugs – Late 60’s outsider rock that doesn’t take itself too seriously. I haven’t laughed like this since I first listened to the Kennedys. Hands down the best record I bought this year.
The rest of this list is in no particular order:
Random Spirit Lover, Sunset Rubdown; The Stage Names, Okkervil River; The Dirt of Luck, Helium; Le Tigre, Le Tigre; Pussy Whipped, Bikini Kill; EP, the Fiery Furnaces; Broken Social Scene, Broken Social Scene; Another Side of Bob Dylan, Bob Dylan; Gyrate +, Pylon; Com Lag (2plus2is5), Radiohead
Okay. You know what? I started listening to Boxer as I wrote about it to get a feel for what I was writing about. Now I really like it. This is crazy because I really didn’t care for it last time I listened to it. Boxer is a heavy album. You have to be willing to carry it. I’ll put it in my Honorable Mentions. Music is a wonderfully funny thing.